First, my technical experience with vented/non-vented is limited. It is generally focused on experience I've had with regular street driven cars, and primarily on the comments of owners. It seems a non-vented unit, properly spec'd and running lower boost for the street, does not pose an issue when everything is going well. However, with higher boost, higher shaft rpm and a little time on the assembly, seal wear can result in modest leak-by if internal pressure leaks develop into the driven gear assembly. The vented or pressure relief setup is just an added feature to avoid the mess of lubricant getting all over everything before you realize other sealing issues exist. If you attach a venting hose to the venting outlet, with a small clear collection bottle, you can see when these internal issues arise by observing lubricant starting to show itself in the bottle. It just seems to me, a vent system is an added feature providing a sense of security for cleanliness, and advance warning indication of other potential issues.